Monday, June 23, 2014
Review: The Moment Collector by Jodi Lynn Anderson
There are two versions of this book. And I have both. Okay, I have this version, the UK edition, in a print paperback. And the US edition, The Vanishing Season, as an eGalley. I do like both covers. Think they are stunning. But the book inside? Hah. It is killing me how awful I found it to be. Which I will try to explain.
I will not talk a lot about this book. Because I don't want to. I just want to say my opinion and be done with it. Be done with this book. But that will probably not happen, as it pissed me off so much. It will probably take me forever to forget it, which is just all kinds of unfair. Sigh. I want to never think of it again. Despite how gorgeous it looks. First, I wanted a murder mystery. And a great romance, like it said. I got neither. What I did got was just.. crap. I'm sorry. But it was. I did not like the writing. It wasn't awful, but I could not connect to a single thing or person. It was just written wrong. Sigh. At least for me. It do make me sad that I couldn't enjoy this book. But. Oh, well.
I didn't like that this book was told from a few different point of views. There was mostly Maggie. But there was also this ghost thingy. And it made no sense. It just didn't. I didn't care at all. Sigh. There were so many things that annoyed me. Like the time frame. It jumped back and forth and I did not understand it. And the dog at the end. Where the hell did it go? Did someone murder it? Take it? It was never answered. That pissed me off too. Sigh. Though, to be honest, I really didn't care that much.
Maggie. She was actually the only thing I liked in this book. But even so, I hated her too. She didn't stand up for herself. She didn't tell her "friends" that they hurt her. That they were being the biggest dicks in the world. And I hate her for that. I would never allow anyone to treat me that way. But Maggie did. Ugh. I'm not pleased. She didn't get her happy ending either. Which just sucked so much and made me even more pissed at this book. Even as I'm writing this I'm getting more and more angry at it all.
Oh, spoilers. Then there is Liam. And Pauline. I actually liked Liam at first. And I liked Pauline a little too. Though she didn't seem real. And sure, I do suppose they were meant to be together. But she was too stupid to do anything about it. So Liam and Maggie started kissing. And they loved each other. They said so! And for fuck's sake. That was the only part of the book I liked. Then Pauline kisses Liam. Maggie sees it. Yet no one tells her. No one speaks with her. She does nothing. Screw them all.
There was supposed to be a murder mystery in this book. But no. The killer is never caught. He just stops after killing many girls. It isn't exciting. It isn't interesting. I didn't get the plot in this book. Because there isn't any. There isn't anything interesting happening. The book was boring. All the time. I guess it was only about Maggie getting screwed over by her friends. Whom she seems to end up forgiving. What the fuck? I'm sorry, but this book pissed me off to no end. I will never forgive it.
I would not recommend this book to anyone. Sure, some might love it. But I'm hoping others will hate it like I did. Because it wasn't good. Not for me.. Sigh. But anyway. Huge thank you to Victoria at Hachette Childrens UK via BooksWithBiteUK. <3 And thank you to HarperTeen on Edelweiss for the auto-approval that made me download this book back in January. <3 I'm sorry that it sucked so much for me. But that's how it is sometimes. Ack. Yeah. The Moment Collector was not a book for me. Hoping I will forget it.
Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)
Once in a while those books come along where you actually feel sorry for the tree that had to die so that book could live because it was such a waste of ink and paper! Thanks for an honest review!ReplyDelete
Ugh, I'm so so sorry to hear this book was such a horrible experience for you! I was quite excited for this one myself, but I've read quite a few negative reviews that are making me want to not read it at all!ReplyDelete
Thanks for always being honest, sweetie!
I did appreciate the writing and found it hard to put down actually. It read so fast that it was a very quick read. I wanted so much more from that plot though. And I was angry at the same things as you were. While reading I even thought to myself, if/when Carina reads this she will HATE it. Glad to know I was right but sad you hated it.ReplyDelete
Ohh Ouch. Thanks for the heads up. I know we tend to hate the same books, so I probably will give this one a skip.ReplyDelete
Oh dear. This book is NOT for me either. I will be staying far away. Thank you for the honest review and for suffering through this so that I don't have to bother. Hope you can cleanse yourself from it with another story soon. xoReplyDelete
I saw another very negative review for this one, and y'all have convinced me I just shouldn't read this. Shame that it looks so good and just isn't. :( Great review though, hon!ReplyDelete
I actually quite liked it, because of the end. It was painful, but I just wish I liked the characters better.. I ended up giving it 3 stars.ReplyDelete